[新聞] 新娘穿牛仔褲拒嫁 新郎獲賠9萬 >> PTT Reader

[新聞] 新娘穿牛仔褲拒嫁 新郎獲賠9萬

 作者  Bqqqa (風雲)                                           看板  Gossiping 
 標題  [新聞] 新娘穿牛仔褲拒嫁 新郎獲賠9萬                                    
 時間  Sun Apr 10 11:57:04 2011                                               

http://udn.com/NEWS/SOCIETY/SOC6/6263862.shtml
新娘穿牛仔褲拒嫁 新郎獲賠9萬
【聯合報╱記者曹敏吉/高雄報導】 2011.04.10 02:52 am

一對新人去年元月辦婚宴,禮車開到新娘家,新娘還穿著牛仔褲告知「不嫁了!」新郎傻
眼,請警員苦勸新娘上車無效,婚事告吹,新郎求償一百四十一萬元,高雄地方法院判賠
九萬元。

拒婚的新娘說,婚前雙方為了歸寧請客人數鬧翻,徐姓男友講話傷了她,她才決定不嫁了
。徐在婚事告吹不久,又交女友,旋即結婚,法官認為他並沒有精神損失,判決新娘只需
賠婚紗等費用共九萬元。

判決指出,住台南的徐姓男子與女友交往年餘,前年十二月訂婚,去年元月結婚,婚前除
拍有婚紗照,並訂妥禮車及新娘秘書等,男方也廣發喜帖,席開卅二桌。

結婚當天,新郎與媒人搭乘禮車到高雄市新娘家迎娶時,新娘穿著家居服及牛仔褲,完全
沒化妝,向新郎的父母表示「不嫁了!」媒人頻勸「沒關係先上車,到台南再補妝」,新
娘不為所動。司機表示不能再拖,向警方報案。

警員到場勸新娘上車,折騰近兩個小時,未能改變新娘心意。女方並將婚紗、結婚禮俗中
的紅燭、香菸等退給男方,雙方不歡而散,徐姓男子憤而提告求償。

新娘出庭表示,徐對她父親說,歸寧時男方只有六人出席,雙方為此爭吵,徐竟揚言「想
清楚再決定是否嫁給我」。她徹夜難眠,決定不嫁。徐說他是一時心急,沒有惡意,且他
說的是「六桌」,不是「六人」。

法官認為,究竟是六人還是六桌,無從查證;但徐要新娘「想清楚」,確實傷了新娘的心
。審酌女方也有支付禮盒等費用,且當天照常出菜開席,只是少了男女主角,用餐的多是
男方親友,判決新娘只需賠償九萬元。



--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 114.45.168.122
→ jarry1007:果真是賠錢貨色                                        04/10 11:57
推 chirmanmao:公主脾氣                                             04/10 11:57
→ BILLYTHEKID:兒戲                                                04/10 11:58
推 LIONDODO:司機第一個反應居然是報警XD                             04/10 11:58
→ tn00706223:.........                                            04/10 11:58
→ rommel1:男方好猛   立刻娶別人                                   04/10 11:58
推 linhsiuwei:這男的真有風度                                       04/10 11:58
→ Balders:也好 避免以後痛苦                                       04/10 11:58
→ jarry1007:不過為啥是司機報案咧? 究~竟~~~司機在這裡扮演什麼角色  04/10 11:58
推 tyrande:剪破它                                                  04/10 11:58
推 retribution:女的也滿猛的 這種事也做得出來                       04/10 11:58
推 frozenmoon:要多學學這種男人,別人不嫁沒關係,去娶別人就好       04/10 11:59
推 nanako81240:少了一筆贍養費  可惜                                04/10 11:59
→ lcy317:婚姻當扮家家酒                                           04/10 11:59
→ weller:高雄不意外                                               04/10 11:59
推 coffee777:男方有GUTS                                            04/10 11:59
→ kao8855:= = 殺小                                                04/10 11:59
→ BILLYTHEKID:新郎眉頭一皺覺得頭頂綠綠的                          04/10 11:59
推 roea68roea68:為什麼要報警= =                                    04/10 11:59
推 pigmoo:司機表示不能再拖,向警方報案? What the poice can do?     04/10 11:59
→ lpllpllpl:那些婚嫁費用要新郎一個人吞下來??                      04/10 11:59
→ kosuke:女方就是想清楚才不嫁的 不過找鴿子實在很多餘              04/10 12:00
→ frozenmoon:POLICE                                               04/10 12:00
推 marsantony:徐在婚事告吹不久,又交女友,旋即結婚←這...          04/10 12:00
→ lpllpllpl:報警要用什麼罪名 詐欺?                                04/10 12:00
→ caparzo:police                                                  04/10 12:00
推 pppwalker:怎麼......只有我覺得這男的自以為是嗎                  04/10 12:01
推 Syoshinsya:真是賠錢的貨色  XD                                   04/10 12:01
→ thisisapen:忍痛娶備胎 這對男方來說是多痛苦的一件事啊 法官應該   04/10 12:01
→ tort:這新郎也怪怪的 馬上娶別人?                                 04/10 12:01
→ thisisapen:是女的吧                                             04/10 12:01
推 xoopter:女人就是不要嫁錯人!                                     04/10 12:01
推 norchen:最後下嫁的那位  不覺得被發洩了嗎?                      04/10 12:01
推 rommel1:結婚要注意時間吧....時辰...事前都算好的.....            04/10 12:01
噓 renmin:決定不嫁就早講,都來迎娶了才靠北,男方被婊很大             04/10 12:01
→ dsfrf: 鴿子 : 你找錯人了,喜鵲住在隔壁                          04/10 12:01
→ carnie:這男的是故意娶備胎氣原配嗎                               04/10 12:01
→ HELLDIVER:報案是報?                                             04/10 12:02
推 GoodFriday:兩邊都很誇張阿..                                     04/10 12:02
→ eatingshit:又交女友   這下男方賠大了 本來一百多萬入帳  顆顆~~~  04/10 12:02
噓 ainor:男方有什麼問題 = =                                        04/10 12:02
→ tort:不結婚報案?? 這男的不嫁也好                                04/10 12:02
推 fantasylee:這種真的不能娶                                       04/10 12:02
推 ligopa:還好沒娶到.....男方好加在                                04/10 12:02
推 chinhan1216:祝女的孤單老死 這麼愛耍脾氣                         04/10 12:02
→ lpllpllpl:我對於婚嫁費用怎麼分 非常有興趣呢                     04/10 12:03
→ missbaby:媒人? 相親的都馬看$$$$$$$$                             04/10 12:03
噓 chiaolin:根本就犯賤.....                                        04/10 12:03
→ g331767:好好笑                                                  04/10 12:03
推 joker099:還好沒娶到+1   ...                                     04/10 12:03
推 Balbeleet:還好沒娶   真替男方慶幸                               04/10 12:04
推 lmc66:男的一堆備胎 不嫁是聰明的                                 04/10 12:04
推 frozenmoon:這新聞告訴我們,男人一定要懂得找替補球員             04/10 12:04
→ altec6021:男方立刻就有女友~ 證明女的真的頭腦夠清楚~ 沒被騙    04/10 12:04
→ rommel1:男方的條件好   一堆人要吧?                              04/10 12:05
→ aal:問題點在女方不嫁不早點告知,存心整男方                      04/10 12:05
→ yuuchilyann:?! 司機為什麼報警? 不過報警好奇怪...?               04/10 12:05
推 CPYH:男的哪裡有問題  那個女的不嫁不會早點說                     04/10 12:05
推 Lailungsheng:想清楚是對的...                                    04/10 12:05
→ lpllpllpl:不嫁可以講啊 婚嫁費用一起攤啊                         04/10 12:05
推 BLACKLAGOON:替補球員馬上上耶 那個備胎這樣也樂意嫁看來不是男方   04/10 12:06
→ BLACKLAGOON:條件很好就是早有...                                 04/10 12:06
推 shyyo7589:支持  就是發狠招  讓對方措手不及的時間都沒有          04/10 12:06
噓 playgirlser:把婚姻當兒戲                                        04/10 12:06
推 harea:男女雙方在比扯的                                          04/10 12:06
→ aspiringchi:女的是故意的吧                                      04/10 12:06
推 tks9527:以結果論而言,女方好像是對的。                          04/10 12:07
→ PttTime:感情真薄弱                                              04/10 12:07
推 Leeheaven:還好沒娶一個公主回家變太后 不嫁可以先講 當天這樣搞..  04/10 12:07
→ frozenmoon:最佳第六人有時候表現會比先發還要好                   04/10 12:07
推 fantasylee:司機才是最冷靜的                                     04/10 12:07
推 GouGousentai:恭喜男方脫離苦海  這種不娶也罷                     04/10 12:07
→ gpgpgpgp:一邊來迎娶了才說不嫁 一邊報警跟立刻交新歡 都有問題     04/10 12:07
推 ktt7756881:公主並                                               04/10 12:08
噓 keykarimba:就算講話機車不能再溝通嗎?其實認真講還不都是一些小事  04/10 12:08
→ lpllpllpl:新郎新娘也才認識一年多就論及婚嫁啊                    04/10 12:08
※ oralsex5566:轉錄至看板 marriage                                 04/10 12:08
→ lpllpllpl:這樣要鞭新郎會不會太早了 而且是去年一月發生的事       04/10 12:09
推 fisikiki:歸寧不是女方辦的嗎?男方出席多少人有差嗎?               04/10 12:09
推 Yaunzunsha:我記得很久之前也有一則類似的新聞...                  04/10 12:09
推 hl4:這法官大概是女的                                            04/10 12:09
推 PacificBlue:男方幹得好                                          04/10 12:09
→ valenci:標題一定要強調牛仔褲????                                04/10 12:10
→ Hollowcorpse:明明就是女方問題大...                              04/10 12:11
→ goldman0204:牛仔褲:躺著也中槍                                   04/10 12:11
→ Alexboo:根本就沒想好也要結婚                                    04/10 12:11
推 Leeheaven:不嫁是她的自由 但存心把場面弄這麼難看是有深仇大恨?    04/10 12:11
推 tatata:的確是想清楚了                                           04/10 12:11
推 anper:女的有病喔...公主                                         04/10 12:12
推 taiwanwang:男的讚啦 免得以後受鳥氣                              04/10 12:12
推 waterspout:這女的亂搞吧  不嫁早幾天講 全部都取消                04/10 12:12
→ Hollowcorpse:不嫁可以先講,人家車都開到家了                     04/10 12:12
→ w94320:把場面弄得難看就是女人的大絕招 因為男人就是死要面子      04/10 12:12
推 eddiecho:不會早點說喔!                                          04/10 12:12
推 mgdesigner:新公主傳奇!                                         04/10 12:12
→ chinhan1216:這種公主 也嫁不出去啦                               04/10 12:13
推 LindsayLohan:這跟穿牛仔褲有甚麼關係 爛標題                      04/10 12:13
推 ignisfatuus:這在演什麼?                                         04/10 12:13
推 arcred:不嫁不會早點講                                           04/10 12:13
→ tort:女的當時已經懷孕了...                                      04/10 12:15
→ bdsl:有時記者提供的數據看看就好,不久是多久?旋即結婚又是多久   04/10 12:16
推 IN:新聞沒提到懷孕吧                                             04/10 12:16
→ lpllpllpl:t大有掛喔                                             04/10 12:16
推 jennyperi:男的自己要前一天落狠話 這叫有風度                     04/10 12:18
推 Nipperdey:清官難斷家務事!                                       04/10 12:18
→ w94320:不過先把肚子搞大也算是一種保障 女的也比較不敢亂來        04/10 12:18
推 Yaunzunsha:婚期相沖硬不嫁 孕女提告獲賠20萬←讓人想到這則新聞    04/10 12:18
→ chinhan1216:哪邊有提到前一天?                                   04/10 12:19
→ Hollowcorpse:是多狠啦?  風度咧... 給機會想清楚了還要怎樣        04/10 12:20
→ Hollowcorpse:早想清楚不嫁了還不講,等對方車隊都到了才那邊張     04/10 12:20
→ Hollowcorpse:誰比較靠悲啊                                       04/10 12:20
推 budos:半斤八兩                                                  04/10 12:21
推 superday:9萬換來更好的人生 值得!                                04/10 12:21
噓 chinliu5566:原來男的講"想清楚"叫作"揚言"喔?女的有病!!           04/10 12:23
推 markbex:這篇新聞寫的不清不楚 無從推斷哪方有錯  而且,結婚是兩   04/10 12:25
推 gundammkiv:這女人 紅了~                                         04/10 12:25
→ markbex:個人的事 鄉民別亂罵比較好  罵錯人你會道歉嗎?            04/10 12:25
推 tkhunter:不嫁?等到拉警報再來哭吧                               04/10 12:28
推 IDRA:           → tort:女的當時已經懷孕了...                   04/10 12:29
推 VieriKing:男人的問題比較大~                                     04/10 12:29
推 a1e:人數來少一點就不爽,幸好婚前就看清,不然婚後就慘了          04/10 12:32
→ ffaatt:那紅包要退嗎                                             04/10 12:32
推 tkr:公主病很重  別人都要求她                                    04/10 12:32
推 jojojoker:徐在婚事告吹不久,又交女友 <== 女方不嫁是對的         04/10 12:33
推 surna:不爽不要嫁阿,哭哭夭夭的                                  04/10 12:33
→ F35:的確不爽不嫁了啊,沒有靠邀                                  04/10 12:37
推 ttnakafzcm:重點在不想嫁又不早講吧                               04/10 12:38
推 klinmmm:好屌的婚禮…                                            04/10 12:41
推 DeathBook:司機怕拿不到錢吧                                      04/10 12:42
→ aoiaoi:只看新聞感覺就短期認識男方有錢女不嫁得好 這男89有問題    04/10 12:43
推 ESPforest:男方哪有什麼問題.公主不嫁若條件好相親看對眼交往就娶   04/10 12:43
→ ESPforest:又不是婚前劈腿最後娶備胎~ 倒是那女的不嫁就他媽早說    04/10 12:44
噓 relaxcloud:不是當事人少說人家男生怎樣 重點式車都開到門口才說不  04/10 12:51
→ relaxcloud:嫁? 到底是在姬掰什麼鬼...好險沒娶                    04/10 12:52
推 LindsayLohan:司機應該是想快點解決問題                           04/10 12:52
→ ikoyumi:看下一篇的判決書吧  還好女生沒嫁這種人 不然誰嫁誰倒楣   04/10 12:53
推 itachi0609:立刻娶別人  還好女方沒嫁                             04/10 12:58
推 IN:連電話告知取消都沒有,還好男生沒娶這種人 不然誰娶誰倒楣      04/10 13:00
推 kery0129:這男的真是狠角色 利害利害~                             04/10 13:02
推 arkin:我到覺得還好沒嫁~~要相信直覺                              04/10 13:03
推 bpooqd:這種事也報警!男角結婚太快了.不然應該可以拿到更多         04/10 13:05
推 yan1102:反正都能立刻娶別人了有差嗎 是他自己叫女生想清楚的耶     04/10 13:07
→ Hollowcorpse:想清楚不會早講?                                    04/10 13:09
推 chinhan1216:反正男的怎樣都沒吃虧                                04/10 13:09
推 wewe123:告吹不久又跟別人結婚  怎嚜看都覺得有問題...             04/10 13:12
推 nicolekay:叫女的想清楚有錯嗎                                    04/10 13:16
推 yadayada:女方有Guts                                             04/10 13:19
推 xFANx:推女方 還好沒嫁  男的說話很傷 還求償咧...                 04/10 13:29
推 Seki:每次看到這種新聞都覺得有趣,推文忠實反映男女觀點大不同     04/10 13:33
推 qDaniel:可憐的男人 出錢出力最後被當凱子婊                       04/10 13:37
推 fantasylee:推文前請先寫男女!!                                 04/10 13:37
推 s866217:推女生  有guts   good job!!                             04/10 13:37
推 zhewei:還好沒娶到這種女人~                                     04/10 13:38
推 minitina:是好險沒嫁...                                          04/10 13:41
噓 Lunachen:司機報警?新娘不嫁是叫警察來抓嗎?                     04/10 13:44
推 LunaTea:推Seki XD 這篇推文很明顯可看出推文者性別~               04/10 13:46
推 carlos5978:結婚前一刻不嫁跟把人肚子搞大不娶是一樣的             04/10 13:46
噓 Lunachen:看到下面的判決書,男人真的很差勁                       04/10 13:46
※ NoPTT:轉錄至看板 joke                                           04/10 13:50
→ BD1983:還好沒娶到這種女人~                                     04/10 13:56
推 iinstan:還好沒嫁這種男人                                        04/10 13:57
推 jeff12280:報警幹嘛..人家不嫁報警勒 警察忙不完                   04/10 14:05
噓 tinjunsei:公主表示:                                             04/10 14:40
噓 lowlow530:報警幹嘛  操                                          04/10 14:44
噓 tiann:還好沒嫁到這種爛男人                                      04/10 14:50
噓 pudings:看後判決文...好險她沒嫁                                 04/10 14:51
噓 AFISH111:純噓賤貨                                               04/10 14:51
噓 yobabe:推文一堆它它還是只能在家打槍吧                           04/10 15:01
推 hahah:男的有什麼問題? 被賤女人婊了 娶別人剛剛好而已            04/10 15:07
→ hahah:難不成你都在馬路上打槍嗎? ^.<                             04/10 15:10
推 Belialdeng:還好女的沒嫁,男的嗆人又不敢承受結果,被婊剛好啦       04/10 15:11
推 laal:報警...太誇張了吧?要用什麼法條來抓人?                      04/10 15:20
噓 T50:台南不意外                                                  04/10 15:20
推 yuma0621:女的問題比較大 小鼻子小眼睛 這種女人不要也罷           04/10 15:26
推 SinosaiAgi:還告人勒   這種沒風度的男人  真嫁了也是悲劇          04/10 15:41
推 ABA0525:女方也滿公主,幸好沒娶!!!當天故意穿牛仔褲,就很明顯       04/10 15:44
噓 pudings:看完了司法院的完整版判決書 只能說最初原因還是在男方     04/10 15:47
→ pudings:最差勁的是結婚前一天才跟女方家長說歸寧是只有6人要去     04/10 15:47
→ pudings:1個月前還跟人說是6桌 這種事不可能聽錯吧...?             04/10 15:48
推 homer0403:先不說男生怎樣 推文還一堆支持女生是怎麼回事           04/10 15:53
→ homer0403:不嫁了不能早點說嗎 一定要等禮車到了才能講??           04/10 15:55
→ pudings:給樓上的 因為後面有貼判決書                             04/10 15:55
推 ccucwc:兩人根本沒真愛麻                                         04/10 15:57
→ b7061334:3一定不正                                              04/10 15:58
推 secscy:不嫁是對的                                               04/10 16:08
→ Belialdeng:結婚前一天才講歸寧人數有變,男的也很賤啊              04/10 16:09
噓 lavigneA:找警察幹嘛啊?...                                       04/10 16:22
推 ooyy:判決書沒說的事情 很多人腦內補完的很開心                    04/10 16:28
推 onlyinptt:其實之後女方還是願意嫁(願意登記)所以根本是在耍性子    04/10 16:42
→ onlyinptt:只想聽到男方道歉 說實在的 小倆口因喜酒人數有變動而爭  04/10 16:43
→ onlyinptt:執 可以理解 也可以婚宴過後再繼續協調(因為那是歸寧宴)  04/10 16:43
→ onlyinptt:還有緩衝時間可處理 但宴客當天 酒席都擺好了人都到場了  04/10 16:44
→ onlyinptt:女方才擺這架子 而且也不是真不嫁 只是要對方道歉 不覺   04/10 16:45
→ onlyinptt:得太不顧大局了嗎? 換個立場來看 男生也不識相 道個歉    04/10 16:46
→ onlyinptt:就可以化解的事~~唉 只能說兩人真的沒有姻緣             04/10 16:47
推 wacow1106:這結了大概過不了多久就離了吧                          04/10 16:48
→ pudings:這種不得已才結的婚,還是別結了吧...                     04/10 16:58
推 jenny21529:前一天晚上才叫人想清楚要不要嫁~是能多早講            04/10 17:26
推 jenny21529:婚前還會說這種話的男人~不嫁也罷= =                   04/10 17:28
推 nanahiei:現實就是籌碼都吃下肚(懷孕),男方當然比較大尾啊          04/10 17:28
推 noname112:要講難聽話就不要事後後悔 吵架都可以撂狠話 以後有得瞧  04/10 17:40
→ noname112:可以馬上結婚 合理懷疑是劈腿 還好沒嫁 否則馬上變外遇   04/10 17:43
噓 tAmoloko:旋即交女友結婚 幸好女生沒嫁!                           04/10 18:02
→ mcharuko:明明就是男生的錯吧,我是男生都覺得是這樣               04/10 19:02
推 lwsun:這種男的不嫁算運氣好                                      04/10 19:05
推 lolololst:這種廢男不能嫁 嫁了最後只是家暴離婚                   04/10 19:42
→ salaen:兩邊出招的殺傷力都頗強,不過以結果看,女方損血比較多       04/10 19:46
推 sting47:幸好沒娶                                                04/10 19:49
噓 whatever0310:weller:高雄不意外  釣到我了^.^                     04/10 19:49
推 iorice:男的問題比較大                                           04/10 20:02
→ shadowsage:我覺得還好 這女的脾氣也不小 兩邊都很衝               04/10 20:10
→ shadowsage:只是女方可以完全不用負擔任何責任 男方卻要付費        04/10 20:10
→ shadowsage:求償合理                                             04/10 20:11
→ shadowsage:女人就是會用大局來衝康 這男的手段不錯 但不夠漂亮     04/10 20:12
推 s851959:不嫁比較好,感覺很恐怖                                  04/10 20:20
噓 GunsNRoses:宅宅的腦補真是不簡單                                 04/10 20:21
推 singarst:男生的問題吧                                           04/10 20:23
推 cfceo:司機怕領不到錢,所以報警                                  04/10 20:31
推 Verse:推女方。這根本就男方沒心要娶。                            04/10 20:50
推 whitelady:男的也太快換新對象了吧而且還馬上就結婚了 = =          04/10 21:07
→ pierse:自己叫人家想清楚 人家想清楚了不行嗎 敢嗆聲就不要怕後果   04/10 21:16
→ pierse:聽他的話"想清楚了"也要告 女生說不嫁也沒後悔阿            04/10 21:17
推 sommerbrisen:二樓真是英明睿智阿,馬上知道這是公主病,應該讓你   04/10 21:45
→ sommerbrisen:當法官去,審性侵案件,可以杜絕很多恐龍判決。       04/10 21:46
→ Parmesan:嫁不嫁取不取是當事人的問題,不過禮車都開到新娘家才說不  04/10 23:08
→ Parmesan:嫁,這點很明顯是女方不對,鬧脾氣也不要拉雙方親友下水     04/10 23:10
→ Yie:                                                            04/11 08:21
→ MPF:警查真的是甚麼都要管(  ̄ c ̄)y▂ξ                          04/11 09:19
噓 spiritia:現在的新聞真的可以亂入 還好沒嫁                        04/11 14:24
→ green001:結婚後會遇到的考驗比結婚前更多,合不來真的不要勉強     04/11 16:27

沒有留言 :

張貼留言