[新聞] 性侵殺人 賠錢求活…法官不甩! >> PTT Reader

[新聞] 性侵殺人 賠錢求活…法官不甩!

 作者  Nacoruru (那摳乳乳)                                    看板  Gossiping 
 標題  [新聞] 性侵殺人 賠錢求活…法官不甩!                                   
 時間  Thu Jan 20 09:34:54 2011                                               

聯合報╱記者鄭惠仁/台南報導】 2011.01.20 03:13 am


男子郭俊偉與謝志宏被控性侵殺害陳姓女子及路過撞見的農夫,

一審到更六審兩人都被各判兩個死刑;更七審時,兩人表示已賠

家屬四百萬和解,希望求得免死,法官認為「賠償是法律上應盡

義務」,仍維持原判。


不少民眾認為犯錯後,只要與家屬和解,就可獲減輕刑責,司法

實務上也不乏這種例子,但未必所有案件都適用;郭俊偉與謝志

宏被控殺人案,就是無法求得減輕的案例。


郭俊偉、謝志宏被控在十一年前看到不認識的陳女頗有姿色,把

陳女押往郭的住處,由郭性侵得逞,謝欲再性侵遭抗拒。隔天凌

晨,郭怕事發,瘋狂刺殺陳女直到力疲,謝再接續砍殺,致陳女

身中四十八刀死亡。兩人行凶時,農夫張清木剛好經過,兩人又

殺死張清木。


郭俊偉犯案時僅十九歲,謝志宏廿一歲,十年來,雖然最高法院

多次發回更審,但高院都維持各兩個死刑判決。兩人為求免死,

除提出已賠償家屬的理由外,還引用去年九月實施的「妥速審判

法」,以案件過八年仍未定讞,嚴重侵害他們接受速審的權利為

由,要求酌量減刑。


台南高分院更七審合議庭認為,從一審至今雖已十年尚未判決確

定,原因在案件發生現場無目擊證人,郭、謝在法院審理中,又

互相推諉責任,提出刑求逼供等多項抗辯,法院為查明真實,難

免有訴訟程序延滯情形。


法官表示,最高法院雖數度發回更審,也都是朝對被告最有利方

向考量,因此並無侵害兩人接受速審的權利,沒減刑必要。審酌

兩人仍無悔意,顯見無法去除殘暴個性,有和社會永久隔離必要。



【2011/01/20 聯合報】@ http://udn.com/


http://udn.com/NEWS/SOCIETY/SOC3/6106585.shtml

只有一個字 爽!

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 123.193.248.174
推 F7:增勇夫表示:看老子哪時候爽就會執行了喔  ^^                    01/20 09:35
→ JackX:不賠錢 也不見的會死                                       01/20 09:35
推 HOLLYQOO:推法官,幹的好                                          01/20 09:35
→ KINGTIGERX:這法官好!                                           01/20 09:35
推 mercury1011:GJ                                                  01/20 09:36
推 Ricrollp:爽                                                     01/20 09:36
推 ERQQ: :D                                                        01/20 09:36
推 OPWaug:這種東西居然可以凹到更七審 台灣的歡樂法律科科            01/20 09:36
推 menshi:受害人家屬有骨氣一點好嗎!400萬就和解...                 01/20 09:37
推 rappig:快執行比較實在                                           01/20 09:37
→ GanLinBa:廢死團表示:                              (這團還真廢)  01/20 09:37
推 realfade:科科                                                   01/20 09:37
推 sugizo0:真想推「安心上路!」                                    01/20 09:37
推 ntouhr:判的好也要上面的有種執行才有用....                       01/20 09:37
→ Ricrollp:拜託  對方有某團在出錢打官司受害者家屬可沒有           01/20 09:37
推 asdfghjkl999:水喔~~                                             01/20 09:38
→ Ricrollp:不和解是要他們全家怎樣                                 01/20 09:38
推 sn7:判死刑有何用 放一堆垃圾在那邊生蟲也不執行 幹你媽的法務部長  01/20 09:38
推 flamedevil:無限上更                                             01/20 09:38
→ jma306:用錢可以買命的話,大家集資買他的命好了                   01/20 09:38
推 carnie:還讓他們多活了十年該感恩了                               01/20 09:38
推 ClubT:GJ                                                        01/20 09:39
推 nicayoung:記得要執行喔                                          01/20 09:39
推 menshi:不和解,當然是打刑帶民啊!不敢打,是怕拿不到錢嗎...      01/20 09:39
推 Huaxx:開心                                                      01/20 09:39
推 SundayPeople:推                                                 01/20 09:40
噓 R75:good job!! 純噓法務部長都不執行死刑                         01/20 09:40
推 chang0206:這時候就超想按讚的 ..                                 01/20 09:40
推 wingthink:爽!                                                   01/20 09:40
推 Benjamin901:法官GOOD JOB,法務部長要快點執行啊                  01/20 09:40
推 hayato01:他們已經多活了十年了!                                  01/20 09:40
推 Kamelie:法官GJ!  快點槍斃死刑犯                                 01/20 09:40
推 sugizo0:講難聽點拖了十幾年的費用,倒不如當時水落石出就兩顆解決  01/20 09:40
推 dspswen:GJ                                                      01/20 09:40
推 linjaha:帥啦!!!!!!!!!                                  01/20 09:41
→ sugizo0:掉他們還省事多了                                        01/20 09:41
→ laechan:哈哈..                                                  01/20 09:41
→ adm123:推,這件事有印象。                                       01/20 09:41
推 tivo:這讓我想推好啊                                             01/20 09:41
推 Ruid:早該槍決了還在拖,垃圾去死                                 01/20 09:41
推 asd25:我還以為法官全死光了 原來還有一個活著                     01/20 09:42
推 p3:爽拉....3好+1好....不過不執行的話沒屁用...                   01/20 09:42
推 carnie:真的好可怕的情節喔 比鬼片還可怕很多                      01/20 09:42
→ laechan:媽的..最高法院七度發回是怎樣                            01/20 09:42
推 simga:怎還不死刑阿~~死驢                                        01/20 09:43
推 Avril1975:GJ                                                    01/20 09:43
推 shadan:帥                                                       01/20 09:43
→ DOMOKID:性侵殺害陳姓女子及路過撞見的農夫      路過的也被ox???   01/20 09:43
推 seashel:可以判死刑定讞 不得上訴嗎                               01/20 09:43
推 pierreqq:沒有哭哭說對不起,再下跪寫個悔過書...沒做全套法官不爽   01/20 09:44
推 deludedfool:農夫:我怎麼躺著也中槍                               01/20 09:44
推 hn15835163:GJ~~不過似乎還有一堆沒執行的                         01/20 09:44
→ deludedfool:聖潔盧表示:                                        01/20 09:44
推 disyou:`法官真英明...人犬團體一定出來鞭                         01/20 09:45
推 v800982004:法官英明!                                            01/20 09:45
→ franktassone:不快死刑,才是浪費國家資源,最高院法官就是喜歡...  01/20 09:45
推 carnie:這個死刑 何時會執行?                                     01/20 09:46
→ sukisam:定讞了執行了再說                                        01/20 09:47
→ carnie:做這種丟臉的事還想活命 他到底想活著幹麻?                 01/20 09:47
推 tomzx:     錢跟命都要  帥!                                      01/20 09:47
→ hacoolman:定讞了嗎?                                             01/20 09:47
推 strive76:這種不趕快槍斃還留在人世衝蝦                           01/20 09:48
→ carnie:我就很好奇姓名都被公布了 要是沒被判死刑出獄後生活好過嗎  01/20 09:48
推 jkiop79315:原來法官還是有好人的~                                01/20 09:48
→ carnie:姓名都被公布了 要是能出獄大概也只能住深山吧              01/20 09:49
推 tomzx:                        改名字很難嗎 ????????????????     01/20 09:50
→ tomzx:     在台灣  一個人可以無條件改兩次名字的樣子             01/20 09:51
噓 serialhon:更七審 最高法院一直發回                               01/20 09:51
推 OOQ:既然要求速審就讓你求仁得仁 來人啊~拖出去槍斃了             01/20 09:52
推 menti:爽!!!!!幹的好 ~~~~~~~~                                    01/20 09:52
推 jukada:讓他死!!!畜生!!                                     01/20 09:52
→ Ricrollp:最高有廢死的  不意外阿                                 01/20 09:52
推 carnie:說的也是喔 可以改名字                                    01/20 09:52
推 xhs:太扯了 希望快一點死型                                       01/20 09:53
噓 Technician:face表示震怒                                         01/20 09:53
→ Ricrollp:之前一個就是被最高發回到下面的乖乖改判無期             01/20 09:53
→ carnie:就是這種人害很多人不敢隨便出門                           01/20 09:53
→ Ricrollp:我們的法院不知道是保護加害的人還是保護被害的人         01/20 09:54
→ carnie:不小心路過也被殺 這樣又讓社會以後會變得更冷漠了          01/20 09:54
推 keepwild:爽 最高法院快確定吧 一直發回是在衝三小                 01/20 09:55
推 pierreqq:和解金給錯人了...                                      01/20 09:56
→ tomzx:    殺路人  這種不判死不行阿  太恐怖了 沒仇也殺           01/20 09:56
推 djmay:兩個被害者真的很可憐                                      01/20 09:56
推 darkfox:趕快死一死吧 已經多活11年了                             01/20 09:58
噓 BIKOMAN:純噓兩個人渣跟不執行死刑  執行了再推回來                01/20 10:00
推 carnie:這種人要是放出來 想到我跟殺人犯有可能在路上遇到 就恐怖   01/20 10:00
→ carnie:不過最重要的 新聞意思是說找不到強有利的證據才拖這麼久嗎  01/20 10:01
→ carnie:雖已十年尚未判決確定 原因在案件發生現場無目擊證人        01/20 10:01
推 evaliao:GJ 不過也要趕快執行再拖下去 難保不會變無期或關幾年出來  01/20 10:02
推 lollipop520:賠錢也是家人幫他付的... 被告哪有錢去賠償...         01/20 10:03
推 yunyo:請人本感化一下                                            01/20 10:03
噓 tiara:多活了10年耶 曾勇夫你他媽的在幹麻!  坐領乾薪嗎?      01/20 10:03
→ overplayer:推法官!!                                             01/20 10:03
推 JackaLMeI:快點判好不好                                          01/20 10:04
噓 han223:它們殺人只要一瞬間  定罪懲罰它們卻要等十幾年             01/20 10:05
→ WizZ:因味呢  我們法律人  執行的是神的工作  所以很慎重的呦       01/20 10:06
推 iele:選票需要就執行個幾個 歐盟免簽需要就又停了                  01/20 10:08
推 orange7:幹得好                                                  01/20 10:08
→ hamigwa:為啥要花人民納稅錢關這種人渣?快點斃一斃當肥料好不好     01/20 10:08
推 yvmi:GJ                                                         01/20 10:11
推 snkykkk:在台灣可以無限次改名好嗎 改兩次不知道是民國幾年的事了   01/20 10:11
推 jackyu:最高法院吃屎,合議庭法官幹得好!有永久隔離於社會之必要     01/20 10:13
推 susanoo:廢死團體表示:                                          01/20 10:14
→ InfinitySA:給箭頭  判死是應該也早該做了 大家這樣就很高興        01/20 10:14
→ InfinitySA:台灣的司法...                                        01/20 10:14
推 False:我覺得可以減刑為一個死刑就好 但條件是要儘快執行           01/20 10:17
→ False:判兩個真的太重了                                          01/20 10:18
→ False:科科                                                      01/20 10:18
→ IWALY:爽啊!!!!!                                                 01/20 10:20
推 besamey:減成一個死刑在更幾審就變無期徒刑或20年囉 當然不能減     01/20 10:21
推 h390s091:                                                       01/20 10:21
推 Sugiros:gj                                                      01/20 10:25
推 iam0718:定讞再說吧 說不定最後輕判十年                           01/20 10:25
推 pichio:學俄羅斯這隻北極熊如何處理索馬利亞海盜,省錢省事:)        01/20 10:25
推 Federerstone:good                                               01/20 10:26
→ Sugiros:十年來一審到更六審   這種人渣早點執行吧                 01/20 10:27
噓 Linethan:什麼爛司法?? 這要審十年????                            01/20 10:28
噓 earthrise:48刀應該一刀一死刑 人渣                               01/20 10:32
→ Insania:更來更去 有啥好更的?                                    01/20 10:32
推 GGBIG:把他神隱吧                                                01/20 10:37
噓 b7061334:這需要等那麼久嗎?  早該死一死了                        01/20 10:38
推 adm123:有點很奇怪,犯人都跟受害者和解,不就代表真的有做嗎?那   01/20 10:38
→ adm123:高院還在懷疑有沒有證人幹嘛?....                         01/20 10:39
噓 a00049g:人渣還不死嗎?                                           01/20 10:41
推 Sango5566:判的好!!                                              01/20 10:42
推 taebo93:這才是好法官                                            01/20 10:42
推 emilyluvsptt:趕快處決吧!!!                                   01/20 10:43
噓 akiss818:槓..有這種國小同學真衰....                             01/20 10:43
推 honafire:讚啦 系赫                                              01/20 10:44
推 kimgordon:我向法官致上我最高的敬意                              01/20 10:44
推 WilliamXZ:快死                                                  01/20 10:47
推 NothingLeft:死好                                                01/20 10:52
噓 nanodiao:廢死聯盟快去救援呀,不過是殺人嘛~~還是有人權滴~        01/20 10:53
推 EX37:快掛了他們                                                 01/20 10:56
→ vadng:早該殺了                                                  01/20 10:57
推 lotoss:快點執行吧  不要再拖了                                   01/20 10:58
噓 Kensirius:廢死呢???                                             01/20 11:02
推 samisami:法官good job                                           01/20 11:07
推 dearevan:這種不想死的就讓牠們去死一死吧                         01/20 11:08
推 AquariusTACO:推法官阿!!!!                                       01/20 11:09
→ dearevan:法官做的好, 寄然想快點結束審判, 那就讓牠們第一個去死   01/20 11:10
推 HateSHE:GJ                                                      01/20 11:10
推 DevilCool:推有觀念的法官                                        01/20 11:11
推 jayhang:GJ                                                      01/20 11:11
推 dearevan:這兩個根本就是人渣, 只想求活出來繼續害人               01/20 11:14
噓 FIEMKI:有些律師 為了錢 連壞人也救 真令人看不起他們 幹           01/20 11:14
推 lamune:讚啦                                                     01/20 11:14
噓 mmmbop:又不會執行  關個十年就可以出來再殺人了 法務部長小心了    01/20 11:20
→ herryhsueh:不管會不會執行 這法官有見地!!!                       01/20 11:26
推 Asucks:死刑快點執行!!!賠錢了不起喔,燒個四百萬冥紙還你啊!   01/20 11:32
推 o760823:爽~!快執行槍決好嗎                                      01/20 11:37
推 ian41360:正直和善良回來了~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~                    01/20 11:44
推 Swashbuckler:                                                   01/20 11:48
推 homechen1990:溫馨                                               01/20 11:48
推 kaku216:有良心的判決                                            01/20 11:49
推 novashine:難得看到優質法官                                      01/20 11:49
推 mudee:和解應該是指民事賠償責任的部份 刑案沒有和解用錢了事的     01/20 11:54
→ afternight:人渣 廢死滾一邊去                                    01/20 11:56
推 mudee:民事賠償只是法官酌量減刑的原因而已  不一定會減            01/20 11:57
推 allan4362:爽                                                    01/20 11:59
推 xiaoyu:這兩個人魔,抄家是剛好而已,有何資格拿來抵命               01/20 12:06
→ kenro:水~~本就該死 還犯這種沒良心的大案                         01/20 12:08
推 ChrisBear:爽快 上訴中的案件不得執行死刑 馬娘娘當法務部長政策  01/20 12:13
推 smileray:GJ 垃圾死好                                            01/20 12:16
推 kloc:笨...400萬給錯人了~給法官說不定可以只關10年                01/20 12:29
推 jimmyhero:拖真久....也挺誇張的                                  01/20 12:30
噓 Ryushuier:替聖潔法師  噓鄉民 沒良心                             01/20 12:33
推 philip571:最高院法官不優質也沒有用                              01/20 12:34
→ nightstory:死好 怎麼不公開凌遲                                  01/20 12:35
推 four0428:記得執行喔 揪咪>.^                                     01/20 12:41
推 bryantlee:GJ!                                                   01/20 12:41
推 kuankubank:難得的法官 不過也要法務部長快執行                    01/20 12:42
推 aadsl:兩個拿刀互殺,哪個還活著可以打麻醉槍斃                    01/20 12:43
推 facewind:推一下法官 費死去死                                    01/20 12:46
推 trunnerko:腦袋傻了 有錢能怎樣                                   01/20 12:47
推 dearevan:這兩個畜牲給再多錢, 也改不了兩個無辜者被殺死的事實     01/20 12:51
推 horb:GJ                                                         01/20 13:02
推 hsien1105:推。但十年也太久了吧。                                01/20 13:12
→ Agamemnonk:1f滾出ptt                                            01/20 13:14
推 smilemiz:犯人家屬連座罰 一等親內一併處死!! 皆大歡喜 科科        01/20 13:15
推 Kamakazi:這種人當然要給他死!!                                   01/20 13:17
→ fan0719:拖了十一年...是我就自殺算了                             01/20 13:29
推 Aaron1107:這兩個畜生快點死一死了啦                              01/20 13:33
推 aphrodite98:耶耶耶!!!!!                                         01/20 13:40
推 shimax:推                                                       01/20 13:48
推 lites:大推!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  01/20 13:50
推 oig528:正義和善良回來了!!!                                      01/20 13:51
噓 RaY4451:就算判死刑也不一定會死阿  賠錢幹嘛~?                    01/20 13:54
推 leemt:法官GJ!                                                   01/20 14:00
推 Zeroyeu:難得有正義法官QQ                                        01/20 14:02
→ pc2990:這兩個男的有點可憐..賠了四百萬 而且還和解了              01/20 14:29
→ pc2990:卻還是被判死刑..                                         01/20 14:29
→ taidocky:幹你娘的哩 吠死團體在哪裡阿 快出來吠阿幹               01/20 14:31
推 SSn:溫馨                                                        01/20 14:34
推 googog:爽                                                       01/20 14:36
噓 lizardh2so4:純噓pc2990  請問他們可憐在哪...有被害人可憐嗎!!!    01/20 15:04
推 pk90290:推                                                      01/20 15:11
推 aries1985:法官GJ                                                01/20 15:13
推 relevart:好法官                                                 01/20 15:15
推 sammyice:不配活在這世上                                         01/20 15:19
推 deeblue:這法官好讚啊  是那位啊~~~                               01/20 15:36
→ deeblue:兩人命400萬...比狗還不如                                01/20 15:36
推 delve:判的好!                                                   01/20 15:36
推 bigtai:推                                                       01/20 15:51
推 whitelady:拜託快點執行死刑吧                                    01/20 15:55
→ whitelady:不懂這兩個人有什麼好可憐的 明明就是死不足惜           01/20 15:56
推 tonykingtwo:最高法院都養些啥法官阿                              01/20 15:57
推 Hans14:有和社會永久隔離必要                                     01/20 15:59
推 flyawaylife:快執行死刑好嗎?                                    01/20 16:20
推 kenotic:農夫...                                                 01/20 16:21
推 vespar:判的好 快讓他們死吧   陳女真的很可憐                     01/20 16:38
推 smayson:GJ                                                      01/20 16:52
推 heiachi:這些死刑犯也要讓人殺他們千刀拉                          01/20 17:03
→ DM1984:讚啦                                                     01/20 17:11
推 emilio5077:爽                                                   01/20 17:27
推 memalina:法官GJ!!!!!!!                                          01/20 17:50
推 makakatw:可憐個屁啊 假如殺你家人再陪你400萬  你覺得犯人可憐?    01/20 17:57
→ makakatw:價值觀真是錯亂到極點                                   01/20 17:57
→ acheer:趕快執行                                                 01/20 18:05
推 circler:浪費社會資源 請快點執行 受害者會死不瞑目                01/20 18:16
推 bigbite:爽 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!                               01/20 18:28
噓 Shadou:為何律師會被酸 就是因為遇到這種還要幫他辯護              01/20 18:48
推 larsur:安新上路                                                 01/20 18:51
推 nickivan:正義法官:速審,斬立決                                 01/20 19:31
推 secscy:司法復活了                                               01/20 19:32
推 tbmouse:這法官真的讚                                            01/20 19:33
推 homer00:水啦!!                                                  01/20 19:35
推 ANDYisME:死                                                     01/20 20:19
推 nerudaliu:人渣 快去絞肉機                                       01/20 20:39
推 RickyRubio:推                                                   01/20 21:50
推 Provance:GJ                                                     01/20 22:12
推 BrownPAN:法官太讚了!! 這種渣越快清理掉越好啊!!!                 01/20 22:50
推 Yie:GJ.                                                         01/20 23:10
推 walker2009:先給個推                                             01/20 23:14
推 swordmylove:法官太讚了!!                                        01/20 23:33
推 ach5813:快執行                                                  01/20 23:53
推 cashko:推法官,這種人應該凌遲處死                               01/21 00:21
推 dreambala:好!                                                   01/21 00:34
推 NewReader:不思反省                                              01/21 04:55
推 Tribute:讚啦!                                                   01/21 09:19
推 rinsoukan:正義不死                                              01/21 09:29
推 srj1986:GJ                                                      01/21 10:07
推 sula0827:死吧                                                   01/21 10:08
推 hero770624:死好XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD                                01/21 12:52
推 pinkeypinkey:GJ!                                                01/21 19:27
推 jackloutter:                                                    01/22 01:58
推 Jiuliano1412:死好                                               01/22 09:48
噓 keyin:還沒定讞,只到高院而已。                                   01/22 10:05
推 disyou:難得有這麼英明的法官                                     01/22 10:32
推 take99999:終於有個正常的法官了                                  01/22 10:49
推 s0300453:推~殺個好                                              01/22 23:43
推 elwyn:正義!                                                     01/24 02:55

沒有留言 :

張貼留言